May 18, 2024

You know how 1 year is 7 dog years, which means for them, every day equals an entire week?

It's no wonder they’re so eager to hang out with us when we come home.

Dogs used to live, hunt and work with us every day, but now we’re working and they stay home with nothing to do.

Thankfully, there are subscriptions that make sure our best buddies are happy and stimulated, and we decided to test them out to see which ones are best.

And the #1 isn’t only the most affordable, but American people love their service with over 6,000,000 happy customers!

Here are our Top 5 Picks this year, with a full review at the bottom of the page:

Advertiser Disclosure

Trusted Consumer Reviews is made up of our own views and opinions. The scoring is determined at our own discretion and should not be used for accuracy purposes. We are able to provide this service for free thanks to the referral fees we receive from a number of service providers. These referral fees may affect the rankings and score assigned to specific vendors. Furthermore, though many vendors appear on the Trusted Consumer Reviews, this DOES NOT imply endorsement of any kind. The information and vendors which appear on Trusted Consumer Reviews is subject to change at any time.


Our Score

Key Features

#1 BEST IN 2024




Price Starts At $2.00/Day

Each BoxDog treat is baked by hand

Caters to allergies

Options for super chewers

Cat boxes available


Pet Treater

Price Starts At $4.00/Day

Toy-only or treat-only options for small dog packs

You can specify diet restrictions and special requests

For every box shipped, they donate an item to an animal shelter

Cat boxes available


Pooch Perks

Price Starts At $3.50/Day

Treats made in the USA

Predominantly natural, organic, non-GMO, and gluten and grain-free

Toys are tested for durability, safety, and fun

Most of their Premium Plush toys are two-ply tough and double-stitched



Price Starts At $2.00/Day

Designed for super chewers with heavy-duty toys

Caters to beef, chicken, and grain allergies

Will replace destroyed toys within 14 days

Toy-only option available

See the rest of the list

We Bought And Tested The Most Popular Dog Toy Services, Here’s Why The BarkBox Is #1

SUMMARY: BarkBox delivers a curated selection of high-quality dog products to your doorstep every month. Every month you get new and original durable toys, treats that are made with healthy ingredients, and chews that promote dental health. The products are chosen based on the size and preferences of the individual dog, with options for small, medium, and large breeds. BarkBox also offers a satisfaction guarantee, allowing customers to receive a replacement or refund if they are not completely satisfied with their purchase.

As a dog owner, I'm always on the lookout for new ways to keep my furry friend happy and entertained.

Even though we’re a big family, we all live our separate lives with work, friends, and hobbies. Dobbie however, only has us.

This guilt plagues every dog owner, but when I heard about BarkBox, a service that makes sure our dogs have something to look forward to every month, I got very interested.

Plus, the idea of having new toys delivered straight to my door sounded like a dream come true.

Loved By Customers

The first thing I did was to look up customer satisfaction on Trustpilot, and I was shocked!

BarkBox has a whopping 4,8 score from 7,784 reviews!

This is by far the best score I’ve seen on any Trustpilot rating which is more than respectable.

With these reviews, you know you’ll get what you pay for.

First Impression

Signing up to BarkBox couldn’t have been easier, I Just headed on over to their website and was welcomed with a 43% discount as they doubled the content of my first box for free. Extremely convenient!

I was happy to see that the signup process involved some questions about Dobbie like size, breed, birthday (they want to celebrate her birthday) and if there are any allergies or food preferences.

Just the fact that they take that into consideration when curating a box of toys and treats is amazing! Talk about service!

What also impressed me was that the first box arrived only 3 days after I placed the order!

On top of that, BarkBox comes with a guarantee saying that if my dog doesn’t like a product, they’ll replace it with a new one!

How Does It Work?

BarkBox is made to be a convenient service so you and your dog can spend more time together.

After you tell them about your dog when signing up, you only need to tell them (if you want) which toys and treats your dog loves and they keep customizing every monthly box with premium toys and treats. That's it.

And In case you want to change your subscription, their customer service is one of the best I’ve been in contact with, and you can see other customers saying the same things on Trustpilot where they are particularly impressed with their effective, polite, and professional service.

My Veterinarian Even Recommend BarkBox

I always like to rely on the advice of my veterinarian when I buy a new product as I know that even though a dog toy is advertised for dogs, it may still be inappropriate.

I'm happy to say that my vet has recommended the toys from BarkBox.

According to her, the toys from BarkBox are designed to keep pets active and help them maintain a healthy weight. And as any pet owner knows, a happy pet is a healthy pet.

My vet also mentioned that keeping my pet active and entertained can help prevent anxiety issues, which is great news for both me and my pet.

Overall, I trust BarkBox's products and the recommendations of my vet to keep my pet healthy, happy, and anxiety-free.

What Do Customers Say?

Benefits Of BarkBox

The latest thing we got from BarkBox was this treat pouch and backpack for Dobbie.

And those two cost more than the subscription If I would have bought them in a pet store!

  1. You save money, as products usually cost a fraction of what you’d pay at retail
  2. You get high-quality, all-natural dog products that are hand-picked by experts
  3. You can access items that aren't always available at local stores
  4. 10% of proceeds donated to rescue organizations
  5. Treats made in the USA or Canada
  6. You can skip the hassle of trying to purchase one-of-a-kind items from specialty shops
  7. It's fun for both you and your dog to unveil what’s inside


I wholeheartedly recommend BarkBox to everyone who has a dog!

The quality of the products they offer is top-notch and their customer service is exceptional.

The treats and toys in each box are carefully curated and my pup absolutely loves them.

I appreciate the fact that they offer a variety of items each season, keeping things fresh and exciting.

Their website is easy to navigate, and the subscription process is straightforward.

Overall, I highly recommend BarkBox to any dog owner looking for high-quality treats and toys for their furry friend.

How To Get BarkBox?

  1. Make sure to order from the official website linked here
  2. Tell them a little bit about your dog
  3. Pick your subscription: month-to-month, 6 months, or 12 months
  4. Enjoy a happy, healthy, and worry-free life with your pet!

Common Questions & Answers

Q: Do you cater to allergies?

Yes, the signup process has a section where they let you inform them about any allergies or preferences so that they can take perfect care of you and your dog!

Q: What kind of items do you get with BarkBox?

Two original toys, two full bags of treats, and one delicious chew—and it's all designed around an original theme and customized to what your dog likes.

Q: Are there any shipping fees?

Yes, there is a $5 flat rate shipping fee. For orders over $35 USD, we offer FREE shipping!

Q: How do I track my box?

Once your package hits the road, you will receive an email with a tracking link so you can keep an eye on where it is.

How Much Does It Cost

BarkBox: (all include 5-6 full-sized products)

  1. Month-to-month: $35/box
  2. 6-month subscription: $26/box
  3. 12-month subscription: $23/box

Super Chewer BarkBox: (all include 6 full-sized products)

  1. Month-to-month: $45/box
  2. 6-month subscription: $33/box
  3. 12-month subscription: $30/box

Get your BarkBox from their official website here >>>


As of May 18, 2024, Ever since BarkBox was on major media for exceeding AAFCO standards, an incredible amount of buzz has been generated. Due to its popularity and positive reviews, the company is so confident in its product and wants people to try it out that they are now offering up to a 50% discount.


Meet Our Expert

Jennifer Ladd

Jennifer is a chef by trade, and also a dietitian. Being an expert in everything food & fitness, we rely on Jennifer to make sure our lunch boxes at the office are as healthy as they can be. She grew up in New Jersey but has since relocated to Boulder, Colorado as she loves the mountains & nature.

Mark from Ohio

just bought BarkBox!

16 seconds ago | TrustedConsumerReview

This site is a free online resource that strives to offer helpful content and comparison features to its visitors. Please be advised that the operator of this site accepts advertising compensation from companies that appear on the site, and such compensation impacts the location and order in which the companies (and/or their products) are presented, and in some cases may also impact the rating that is assigned to them. To the extent that ratings appear on this site, such rating is determined by our subjective opinion and based on a methodology that aggregates our analysis of brand market share and reputation, each brand’s conversion rates, compensation paid to us and general consumer interest. Company listings on this page DO NOT imply endorsement. Except as expressly set forth in our Terms of Use, all representations and warranties regarding the information presented on this page are disclaimed. The information, including pricing, which appears on this site is subject to change at any time.